Logo image
Sophistication-Maturity
Book chapter

Sophistication-Maturity

Kirk Heilbrun, David DeMatteo, Christopher King and Sarah Filone
Evaluating Juvenile Transfer and Disposition, pp 158-184
2017

Abstract

Juvenile Offenders Forensic Mental Health Treatment Amenability Multidimensional Treatment Foster Care Self-reported Delinquent Behavior Adolescent’s Maturity Juvenile Court Male Juvenile Offenders Forensic Mental Health Assessment Kent Criteria Forensic Mental Health Professionals Juvenile Competence Juvenile Transfer Antisocial Behavior Disposition Contexts Transfer Decisions Developmental Maturity Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory Adolescent Legal Decision Makers Stand Trial Evaluations Disposition Decisions Juvenile Court Judges Intra-class Correlation Criminal Sophistication Family Court Judges
This chapter focuses on the third criterion relevant to transfer and reverse transfer decisions: sophistication-maturity. It reviews the empirical research that has examined this construct after describing the legal context for sophistication-maturity, with a particular emphasis on studies that have investigated correlates of sophistication-maturity and the predictive validity of the construct in the contexts of transfer and reverse transfer decisions. The chapter then describes various approaches for assessing sophistication-maturity, and concludes with a synthesis of the practice literature and a focus on best practice. The construct of sophistication-maturity is relevant in a number of legal contexts involving justice-involved adolescents, including adjudicative competence, waiver of Miranda rights, eyewitness testimony, and the treatment of detained youth with behavioral problems. Synthesizing the practice literature, Salekin (2015a) suggested that forensic mental health professionals use a test battery that includes intelligence tests, achievement tests, measures of child and adolescent psychopathology, strengths-based measures, and a measure that specifically assesses the psycho-legal construct of sophistication-maturity.

Metrics

4 Record Views

Details

Logo image