Published, Version of Record (VoR)CC BY-NC V4.0, Open
Abstract
Article Education Ethics Ontology Philosophy Philosophy of Medicine Political Philosophy Theory of Medicine/Bioethics
This paper continues a debate about the following claim: an agent punishes someone only if she aims to harm him. In a series of papers, Bill Wringe argues that this claim is false, I criticize his arguments, and he replies. Here, I argue that his reply fails.