Journal article
The Use of Psychopathy Assessments in Canadian Case Law: A Quantitative and Qualitative Survey of Court Records From 1980 to 2023
Psychology, public policy, and law, v 32(1), pp 73-94
01 Feb 2026
Featured in Collection : UN Sustainable Development Goals @ Drexel
Abstract
This study investigated the use of psychopathy assessments in Canadian courts between 1980 and 2023. We reviewed 3,315 court cases and found that psychopathy assessments were used in two distinct ways: either as a clinical measure of psychopathy or exclusively for risk assessment purposes. Psychopathy assessments are most commonly introduced in court by prosecutors, with the Hare Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R) being the most frequently used tool. The use of psychopathy assessments increased by 858% from the year 2000 to its peak in 2013, followed by a 10-year gradual (63%) decline. There was evidence of adversarial allegiance where prosecution-retained experts gave defendants higher PCL-R scores (d = 1.08) compared to defense-retained experts. PCL-R assessments showed poor reliability when comparing paired scores between prosecution and defense experts, suggesting a high risk of Type 1 and Type 2 errors. Intraclass correlation coefficient between prosecution- and defense-retained experts was .079 (95% confidence interval [CI] [-0.12, 0.34]), where 40% of experts had a >= 5.9 points scoring difference. A qualitative analysis of 183 expert testimonies on the perceived forensic risk and treatment prospects associated with psychopathy showed significant variability in expert testimonies. Most experts linked psychopathy to a high risk of recidivism (72.36%) and described it as a categorically untreatable condition (50.63%), where many experts also stated that treatment makes psychopathic persons worse (15.82%). These findings suggest that some expert testimonies on psychopathy are not aligned with the empirical research. We discuss the potential implications for legal practitioners and comment on the future role of psychopathy assessments in Canadian courts.
Metrics
5 Record Views
Details
- Title
- The Use of Psychopathy Assessments in Canadian Case Law: A Quantitative and Qualitative Survey of Court Records From 1980 to 2023
- Creators
- Rasmus Rosenberg Larsen - University of TorontoEmilie Ades - Queen Mary Univ, Wolfson Inst Populat Hlth, London, EnglandYashika Shroff - Queens UniversitySonya Anna McLaren - Carleton UniversityStephanie Griffiths - Okanagan Coll, Dept Psychol, Kelowna, BC, CanadaJarkko Jalava - Okanagan Coll, Dept Interdisciplinary Studies, Kelowna, BC, CanadaDavid DeMatteo - Drexel University, Thomas R. Kline School of Law
- Publication Details
- Psychology, public policy, and law, v 32(1), pp 73-94
- Publisher
- Amer Psychological Assoc
- Number of pages
- 23
- Resource Type
- Journal article
- Language
- English
- Academic Unit
- Psychological and Brain Sciences (Psychology); Thomas R. Kline School of Law
- Web of Science ID
- WOS:001581320000001
- Other Identifier
- 991022121726604721
UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
This publication has contributed to the advancement of the following goals:
InCites Highlights
Data related to this publication, from InCites Benchmarking & Analytics tool:
- Collaboration types
- Domestic collaboration
- International collaboration
- Web of Science research areas
- Health Policy & Services
- Law
- Psychology, Multidisciplinary