Files and links (1)
SubmittedOpen Access (License Unspecified), Open
Journal article
Variance partitioning of stream diatom, fish, and invertebrate indicators of biological condition
Freshwater science, v 31(1), pp 182-190
01 Mar 2012
Featured in Collection : UN Sustainable Development Goals @ Drexel
Abstract
Stream indicators used to make assessments of biological condition are influenced by many possible sources of variability. To examine this issue, we used multiple-year and multiple-reach diatom, fish, and invertebrate data collected from 20 least-disturbed and 46 developed stream segments between 1993 and 2004 as part of the US Geological Survey National Water Quality Assessment Program. We used a variance-component model to summarize the relative and absolute magnitude of 4 variance components (among-site, among-year, site 3 year interaction, and residual) in indicator values (observed/expected ratio [O/E] and regional multimetric indices [MMI]) among assemblages and between basin types (least-disturbed and developed). We used multiple-reach samples to evaluate discordance in site assessments of biological condition caused by sampling variability. Overall, patterns in variance partitioning were similar among assemblages and basin types with one exception. Among-site variance dominated the relative contribution to the total variance (64-80% of total variance), residual variance (sampling variance) accounted for more variability (8-26%) than interaction variance (5-12%), and among-year variance was always negligible (0-0.2%). The exception to this general pattern was for invertebrates at least-disturbed sites where variability in O/E indicators was partitioned between among-site and residual (sampling) variance (among-site = 36%, residual = 64%). This pattern was not observed for fish and diatom indicators (O/E and regional MMI). We suspect that unexplained sampling variability is what largely remained after the invertebrate indicators (O/E predictive models) had accounted for environmental differences among least-disturbed sites. The influence of sampling variability on discordance of within-site assessments was assemblage or basin-type specific. Discordance among assessments was nearly 2x greater in developed basins (29-31%) than in least-disturbed sites (15-16%) for invertebrates and diatoms, whereas discordance among assessments based on fish did not differ between basin types (least-disturbed = 16%, developed = 17%). Assessments made using invertebrate and diatom indicators from a single reach disagreed with other samples collected within the same stream segment nearly 1/3 of the time in developed basins, compared to 1/6 for all other cases.
Metrics
Details
- Title
- Variance partitioning of stream diatom, fish, and invertebrate indicators of biological condition
- Creators
- Robert E. Zuellig - US Geol Survey, Ft Collins Sci Ctr, Ft Collins, CO 80526 USADaren M. Carlisle - US Geol Survey, Natl Ctr 413, Reston, VA 20192 USAMichael R. Meador - US Geol Survey, Natl Ctr 413, Reston, VA 20192 USAMarina Potapova - Acad Nat Sci Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA 19103 USA
- Publication Details
- Freshwater science, v 31(1), pp 182-190
- Publisher
- SOC FRESWATER SCIENCE
- Number of pages
- 9
- Resource Type
- Journal article
- Language
- English
- Academic Unit
- Biodiversity, Earth, and Environmental Science (BEES)
- Web of Science ID
- WOS:000309904300016
- Scopus ID
- 2-s2.0-84878324427
- Other Identifier
- 991019168492804721
UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
This publication has contributed to the advancement of the following goals:
InCites Highlights
Data related to this publication, from InCites Benchmarking & Analytics tool:
- Collaboration types
- Domestic collaboration
- Web of Science research areas
- Ecology
- Marine & Freshwater Biology